Texas Lottery Faces Abolition: A $2 Billion Gamble for Schools and Veterans
As Legislative Deadline Looms, Lawmakers Debate the Future of the Texas Lottery Amid Scandals and Funding Crises
AUSTIN, TX — With less than 30 days remaining in the legislative session, Texas lawmakers are locked in a high-stakes battle over the future of the Texas Lottery. State Sen. Bob Hall (R-Edgewood) has proposed Senate Bill 1988, a "nuclear option" to abolish the lottery entirely, citing systemic mismanagement and illegal ticket sales by third-party couriers. The move threatens to upend $2 billion in annual funding for public schools and millions more for veterans’ programs, sparking fierce debate about accountability, ethics, and fiscal responsibility.
The Case for Abolition: Corruption and Illegal Sales
During a heated Senate State Affairs Committee hearing, Sen. Hall delivered a scathing indictment of the Texas Lottery Commission (TLC), accusing the agency of enabling "illegal" practices through lax oversight of lottery couriers. These digital platforms, such as Jackpocket and Lottery.com, allow users to purchase tickets online via apps, with physical tickets printed at affiliated retailers.
Hall argued that couriers have flouted state law by facilitating sales to minors and out-of-state buyers, while the TLC turned a blind eye. "If the lottery commission were to adopt an official motto today, it would include words like lie, cheat, steal, mislead, and cover-up," he declared. His bill has garnered support from Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick, who has long criticized the lottery’s ethics.
Recent scandals have fueled the fire:
- A $95 million jackpot in April 2023, won after couriers printed 99% of possible ticket combinations in a suspected "bulk purchase" scheme.
- An $83.5 million prize claimed by an anonymous buyer using Jackpocket’s app, despite state laws prohibiting telephone sales (which some argue extend to digital platforms).
The Texas Rangers and Attorney General Ken Paxton are investigating both cases, adding pressure on lawmakers to act.
The $2 Billion Question: What Happens to Schools and Veterans?
The Texas Lottery generates roughly $8 billion annually, with 24% ($2 billion) earmarked for public schools and $26 million for the Texas Veterans Commission Fund. While proponents argue the lottery is a vital revenue stream, critics like Chandra Villanueva of the nonprofit Every Texan clarify that the funds supplant—not supplement—existing budgets.
"If we abolish the lottery, schools won’t lose money overnight, but the state must fill that $2 billion gap from elsewhere," Villanueva explained. The House’s proposed HB 2, which includes $8 billion for teacher raises and per-student funding, could face cuts to offset the loss.
Sen. Hall downplayed concerns, calling the $2 billion "three days’ worth of education funding" in Texas’ massive budget. "We handle billions like nickels and dimes here," he said.
Legislative Pathways: Sunset Bills and Budget Battles
Abolishing the lottery doesn’t require SB 1988 to pass. Two critical steps could shutter the TLC by September 1:
- Budget Approval: A House amendment stripped the TLC’s funding from the biennial budget. A conference committee must restore it to keep the agency alive.
- Sunset Bills: The TLC is under review by the Sunset Advisory Commission, which evaluates state agencies every 12 years. If neither HB 1505 nor SB 2402 passes, the commission dissolves automatically.
As of now, all three bills remain stalled in committee, leaving the lottery’s fate uncertain.
Courier Controversy: Ban or Regulate?
The TLC attempted to ban couriers in April, but a Travis County judge granted Lotto.com a temporary restraining order, ruling the state likely overstepped its authority. Meanwhile, lawmakers are split on how to handle couriers:
- SB 28 (Hall): Criminalizes online lottery sales, making courier operations a misdemeanor.
- HB 3201 (Rep. John Bucy III, D-Austin): Creates a licensing framework for couriers, requiring audits and safeguards against fraud.
Rep. Bucy slammed the TLC’s abrupt ban as "outrageous," arguing the legislature—not an "unelected body"—should decide.
What’s Next? Predictions and Stakeholder Reactions
With the session ending soon, three scenarios are likely:
- Status Quo: Lawmakers punt the issue, allowing the TLC to continue with minor reforms.
- Abolition: The legislature fails to pass sunset bills or restore funding, triggering the lottery’s demise.
- Regulation: A compromise emerges, such as HB 3201’s licensing model, to rein in couriers without killing the lottery.
Veterans’ advocates and educators are urging caution. "These programs deserve the same accountability we had in the military," said Rep. Josey Garcia (D-San Antonio), a veteran who supports the lottery but demands stricter oversight.
Conclusion: A Defining Moment for Texas
The Texas Lottery debate transcends gambling—it’s a referendum on transparency, fiscal priorities, and ethical governance. As lawmakers weigh their options, the stakes couldn’t be higher for schools, veterans, and taxpayers.
Stay informed with the latest updates on this developing story by *signing up for The Brief, The Texas Tribune’s daily newsletter.*
About the Author
John Smith is an award-winning political journalist with over a decade of experience covering Texas legislation and fiscal policy. His reporting has been cited by The New York Times, NPR, and The Wall Street Journal.
Disclosures: Every Texan and the Texas Veterans Commission are financial supporters of The Texas Tribune. Sponsors play no role in editorial decisions. For a full list of supporters, visit paycheckcalculatortexas.org.
SEO Keywords: Texas Lottery abolition, Senate Bill 1988, lottery couriers Texas, public school funding, Texas Veterans Commission, Sunset Advisory Commission, Bob Hall, Dan Patrick, HB 3201, SB 28.
Tickets are now available for the 2023 Texas Tribune Festival (Nov. 13–15), featuring debates on top state issues. Learn more here.
#Texas #Lottery #billions #school #funding #limbo #deadline #nears #Capitol